Risk Assessments & Safe Working
What Is the Hierarchy of Control?
Guidance dated 11 September 2026
The hierarchy of control is a way to choose measures that reduce risk, starting with removing the hazard where possible. It helps you look beyond instructions and personal protective equipment when a better change to the task could protect people more reliably.
HSE presents five levels: elimination, substitution, engineering controls, administrative controls and personal protective equipment. Consider them in that order. In practice, a task may need several layers working together. [9]
Eliminate the hazard where you can
Elimination means removing the source of harm from the activity. The strongest opportunity often comes before equipment is purchased, a process is designed or a maintenance task is specified.
For example, changing a layout so goods no longer have to be carried up steps removes that part of the handling task. Arranging for components to arrive in the required size may remove an on-site cutting operation. Both examples require checking the wider process, including delivery and installation.
Ask whether the task needs to happen at all, whether it can happen somewhere safer and whether a design decision could remove it. These questions are easier to act on early than after the work has started.
Substitute with a safer option
Where elimination is not possible, consider replacing the material, equipment or process with a less hazardous alternative. A product change should be assessed in context, rather than accepted solely because its label sounds reassuring.
A substitute cleaning product might reduce one health hazard but introduce a different storage or handling issue. Check whether it works at the required concentration, how it will be dispensed and whether employees could mix it with another product.
Substitution is a decision about the whole use of the alternative. Keep a record of why it is safer and what controls it still requires.
Use engineering measures to separate people from harm
Engineering controls change the physical conditions. Examples include suitable machine guarding, local exhaust ventilation and physical separation between pedestrians and vehicles. The design must suit the task and be maintained so it continues to work. [13]
Think about how the control could be bypassed or defeated. A barrier that forces people into an awkward detour may encourage shortcuts. An extraction hood positioned away from the source may look reassuring while missing the exposure.
Involve the people using the control before finalising it. A well-designed measure should fit the activity, including setup, cleaning and maintenance.
Support the system with clear working arrangements
Administrative controls include instructions, training, supervision, access restrictions and arrangements that reduce exposure. They are often necessary, but depend on people understanding and following them consistently.
Make the instruction specific. “Keep clear of vehicles” leaves the employee to interpret the safest route. A defined route, agreed delivery arrangements and supervision at unusual vehicle movements give the instruction a working structure.
Check whether workload and scheduling support the safe method. If staff can meet the production target only by bypassing it, the problem needs management attention.
Select suitable personal protective equipment
PPE is the final level in the hierarchy. It may still be essential, including while other controls are being developed or where a remaining risk needs personal protection. Its use should follow an assessment of the task and the available controls. [9]
Choose equipment that is suitable for the exposure, compatible with other equipment and usable by the individual. Explain its limitations, care and replacement arrangements. A purchase record does not show that the equipment fits or is being used correctly.
Where respiratory protection is needed, selection and use may require specialist input. Do not assume that any mask protects against every airborne hazard.
Apply the hierarchy to a real decision
Imagine employees repeatedly carry heavy boxes across a busy work area. First consider changing the delivery or storage arrangement to remove the carrying. Then consider smaller loads, suitable handling equipment and separation from other activity. Training and any necessary PPE support that redesigned task.
Write down why the chosen measures are appropriate and check them during actual use. If the only action is “remind staff”, revisit the higher levels before treating the assessment as complete.
FAQs
Do I have to use every level
No. Consider the options in order and choose a suitable combination. A hazard that can be removed may not need the same additional measures as one that remains.
Is PPE ever the right answer
Yes, where the assessment identifies a need. It should form part of a considered control strategy, with proper selection, training and maintenance.
Can training replace an engineering control
Do not assume it can. Judge whether the risk can be adequately controlled and whether a stronger physical measure is reasonably practicable. A training record does not make an exposed hazard safe.
How Secure Safety Solutions can help
We can help challenge assessments that rely heavily on warnings, training and PPE. Working with your team, we will consider how the task could be changed and what evidence would show the chosen controls are effective.
Get advice on controlling workplace risks
Sources and further reading
- [9] HSE: Managing risk using PPE and the hierarchy of controls
- [13] HSE: Principles of good control practice
General guidance. The arrangements you need depend on your activities, premises and location.
