← Knowledge Hub

Audits & Compliance

What Should a Health & Safety Audit Include?

A useful health and safety audit examines how your arrangements are designed, how they work and whether they control the risks in your business. It should give you a clear view of strengths, gaps and priorities, supported by evidence.

The scope matters. A focused review of contractor management will answer different questions from a wider audit of the management system. Agree what is being assessed before collecting documents or arranging visits.

Start with the questions the audit needs to answer

Is the business growing faster than its arrangements? Are managers applying procedures consistently? Has a client raised concerns? Do directors need assurance that actions from previous reviews have been completed?

These questions help define the locations, activities and evidence to include. Set out the criteria being used, such as applicable legal duties, company requirements or a named management standard where that is genuinely within scope.

A general health and safety audit is not automatically a certification audit. Nor is it a guarantee that every legal issue has been identified. The report should make its scope and limitations clear enough for managers to use the findings appropriately.

Review responsibilities and management arrangements

Check how leadership sets expectations, allocates resources and receives information. Look at the policy, responsibilities, competent assistance and consultation arrangements.

Then follow an issue through the system. If a supervisor identifies an unsafe activity, how is it escalated, who decides what to do and how is completion checked? A process that depends on one person remembering an email may fail during absence or turnover.

HSE’s management guidance emphasises planning, implementation, monitoring and review. An audit can test how well those elements connect in your organisation. [4]

Examine the controls for significant risks

Select activities that matter to the business. Depending on the operation, these might involve equipment, hazardous substances, fire arrangements, manual handling, work at height or contractor work.

Compare the documented requirements with workplace conditions. Where the assessment specifies a control, establish whether it is present, understood and effective. Where specialist examinations or assessments sit outside the audit scope, check how they are commissioned and followed up.

An auditor observing a machine cannot necessarily confirm its full technical compliance. The distinction between management evidence and specialist technical examination should remain clear.

Use documents and conversations together

Policies, risk assessments, training records, inspection reports and maintenance information all contribute evidence. They should be tested through discussion and suitable sampling, rather than accepted solely because the file exists.

Ask staff to explain how they carry out a task or report a defect. Speak to managers about the decisions behind the arrangements. Differences between the written system and people’s explanations are useful lines of enquiry.

HSE’s leadership guidance recommends attention to preventive information as well as incident data. A record of completed maintenance or competence checks can reveal something that an accident total cannot. [38]

Make findings clear enough to act on

Each finding should identify the issue, the evidence and the required outcome. Distinguish an observed failure from a suggestion for improvement, and avoid presenting every recommendation as a legal breach.

An illustrative finding might state that three sampled new starters were allocated a task before the required supervised sign-off. The next step is to address their competence and investigate why the allocation process allowed this, rather than simply recreate missing signatures.

Give actions owners and realistic dates based on risk. Urgent concerns should be raised when identified, without waiting for the polished report.

Close the loop after the audit

Track actions to completion and verify that they address the cause. “Procedure updated” may be an incomplete response if employees have not been briefed or equipment remains unsuitable.

Review patterns across findings. Repeated overdue inspections may reflect unclear ownership, insufficient resources or a system nobody can access. Treating each missed inspection separately can leave that underlying problem untouched.

HSE describes monitoring and investigation as ways to understand failures and improve controls. Use the audit as part of that ongoing management process. [39]

FAQs

Is an audit the same as an inspection

They overlap, but an inspection usually focuses on workplace conditions or activities at a point in time. An audit typically examines the wider arrangements and supporting evidence against agreed criteria.

Must every business have an annual external audit

There is no blanket requirement for an annual external audit of every business. Monitoring arrangements should suit the risks; contracts or management standards may add particular requirements.

Should we tidy the records before an audit

Make records accessible and provide accurate information. Do not conceal gaps or retrospectively create evidence of checks that did not happen. The audit is more useful when it reflects reality.

How Secure Safety Solutions can help

We provide independent audits and inspections that connect documentation with working practice. We can work alongside your internal team to establish the scope, identify priorities and produce findings that managers can use.

Discuss an audit or inspection

Sources and further reading

General guidance. The arrangements you need depend on your activities, premises and location.